Motorino pizzeria.

Catching you up on recent ESPN content:
* Cape Cod League All-Star Game notes
* Team USA notes, including potential #1 overall pick Carlos Rodon
* K-Rod trade analysis
* Matt Garza trade analysis
* Last week’s Klawchat
* Last week’s Behind the Dish, featuring Phillies beat writer Matt Gelb

Continuing my Food and Wine pizza crawl, one pizza at a time, I stopped by NYC’s Motorino on Thursday night en route from Delaware to Cape Cod. Motorino was on the list and the recommendation was seconded by one of you, and it more than lived up to expectations, a solid 60 or 65 on the 20-80 scale.

I went with the pizza with Brussels sprouts, smoked pancetta (so an Italian bacon, in essence), garlic, and “fior di latte,” which is a fancy way of saying fresh cow’s milk mozzarella. Although Motorino bills itself as authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, they’re not quite at that standard; the center of a Neapolitan pizza should be wet, and impossible to pick up as a slice, while Motorino’s crust is thin at the center but strong enough to hold together, without any pooling of liquid. Americans don’t care for that traditional wet center, so many pizzerias avoid it, but you can’t truly be Neapolitan without it.

The crust itself was soft with good tooth, not as crispy at the exterior as I like (you only get that from very hot ovens, like Bianco’s), but hitting that spot where you know it’s pizza but you get moments where you think you’re chewing very fresh artisan bread. Brussels sprouts are a bit of a trendy ingredient, but I happen to like them a ton – maybe I’m a trendsetter, as I’ve been making them weekly when in season since I first got Joy of Cooking in 1998 – and they’re very good for you, so I tend to order them if they’re on a menu. Like most members of the cabbage family, they pair well with smoked pork products, with pancetta giving you more pork/ham flavor than you get from standard American bacons, where you get more smoke flavor and less meat. Anyway, Motorino’s combo was just a bit too heavy on the garlic but otherwise outstanding, prompting me to eat more than was reasonable for one person who had actually had dinner four hours earlier.

The place is tiny, and very dark – if I hadn’t been reading a book on my iPad, I wouldn’t have been able to read while I waited – and does a brisk takeout business. At about 10 on a Thursday night, it was half empty, but service was still prompt and my pizza came out very quickly, enough that I was in and out of the restaurant inside of 40 minutes. I liked Ribalta quite a bit but Motorino’s traditional pizza was better than Ribalta’s.

Nine down, 33 to go. I crawl on…

Comments

  1. Keith I’m guessing you’ll get 10,000+ food recommendations in NYC but I guess it can’t hurt to give a few more (I have been dining off your Phoenix lists for years since moving out here). For a great plain slice or fresh mozz, tomato, and basil slice, try NY Pizza Suprema around 30th street and 8th ave. I’ve got a few others but the place you MUST try is Rocket Pig, which is on like 24th and 10th ave. It’s a small, almost hidden store front that serves a single entree: a divine roasted pork sandwich. It’s expensive but well worth it, although I’m not sure the “picnic” meal is really worth getting as the side items were nothing special. They also have some pretty nice salty bacon caramels.

  2. I made it there last night. Also had the brussels sprouts pizza, without the pancetta and with mushrooms added in deference to a vegetarian. The crust was among the very best I’ve eaten, and our center wasn’t strong enough to hold together. The pancetta probably would have helped but a sprinkling of red pepper took the pie up to excellent. Also the tira misu was top-notch.

  3. Hi Keith,

    Thanks for the review of The Dinner. What I found curious was the mention of detection of this “disorder” in the amniotic fluid. Sociopathy is certainly not detectable in amniotic fluid, and is often not as directly heritable as other disorders, such as diabetes. Was Herman Koch making up his own disorder (similar to sociopathy), or was it a different disorder?