Nashville eats, 2015 edition.

My annual ranking of the top 25 MLB players under 25 is up for Insiders, as is another draft blog post on Vanderbilt’s Carson Fulmer and Dansby Swanson. My weekly Klawchat transcript is up. I also appeared on actor Nate Corddry’s Reading Aloud podcast, talking mostly about books and pizza with a little baseball chatter thrown in.

Nashville has more great places to eat than I could possibly hit in one scouting trip, even if I stayed five or six nights. And new ones are constantly opening, which was my aim on my two trips there in April since several of them have become so popular either with critics or locals.

The 404 Kitchen (restaurant not found error?) was the best meal I had while in Nashville; it’s a small place, seating about 40, and the menu changes daily depending on what ingredients were available that particular day. When I was there, there was a farm egg starter that was just a yolk served on a plate of al dente farro with mixed wild mushrooms and herbs, with enough of the dark cooking liquid to form a sauce when I mixed the yolk into the grains. Farro is an ancient form of wheat that has long been eaten in southern Italy the way we might eat rice or barley, but since it’s a whole grain it’s more nutritious than white rice, and I greatly prefer its flavor to that of barley. I would have preferred the farro to be a little more cooked – this was Al Dente’s cousin, Trey Dente – but the dark, earthy, lemony sauce was superb in its balance of acid and umami. I made an improvised version of the dish over the weekend using mixed dried mushrooms, reconstituting them for the cooking liquid, and using steel cut oats (a.k.a. groats) because I couldn’t get farro.

The entree was the least successful of the three dishes, a wahoo fillet served with some spring vegetables, but lacking a little punch to spruce up the mildness of the fish itself. (My first experience with wahoo was on my honeymoon in Bermuda twenty years ago, at the White Horse Tavern. They served a fried wahoo sandwich that was so frequently confused with chicken by tourists that they had a sign up saying, “No, the fried wahoo isn’t actually chicken.”) The mixture underneath the fish included some fingerling potatoes and sunchokes, easily my favorite part of the dish. The dessert was a chocolate “budino” that was thicker than most budinos or mousses, semi-sweet with bits of almond and drunken tart cherries; I like darker chocolates but this was close, and it was rich enough that it was best shared.

Two Ten Jack is Nashville’s first izakaya/ramen house, and while I am no judge of ramen or broth at all – I’ve had real ramen maybe three times in my life – I thought the tonkotsu (pork broth) ramen at Two Ten Jack was spectacular. Tonkotsu is made from pork bones, often trotters (yep, that’s pig feet), so the flavor is meatier than any other stock or broth made from chicken or beef. It’s also thicker because the preparation of the stock involves slowly poaching some pork fat and then whisking it into the liquid to form an emulsion. Two Ten Jack’s version has a little pork floating on top as well as the noodles adn aromatics you’d expect to have, but I would gladly drink this stock by the pint. The restaurant also offers sashimi, a few other raw fish preparations (including a tuna poke that I thought needed more acidity), and yakitori skewers you can order by the stick for about $3-5 each. They also serve several cocktails built around the distilled rice spirit shochu, including one that mixes it with their own house-made tonic water.

Several of you have recommended Mas Tacos Por Favor for a while, although it’s much easier now that they have a brick and mortar location right across the street from The Pharmacy, a great burger joint that also serves amazing tater tots. Mas Tacos offers five different taco options that look like they rotate or change frequently; when I was there there were options with beef, pork, chicken, shrimp, and a vegetarian one with sweet potato. The pulled (braised) pork was the easy winner over the chicken, as the pork had the flavor of carnitas without being too heavy, while I thought the chicken was too bland and I mostly got the flavors of the toppings. You can get one elote (grilled seasoned corn on the cob with paprika and cotija cheese) for $3, which I recommend, and a small plate of maduros (fried sweet plantains), which I probably wouldn’t. They also sell aguas frescas in varying flavors, but were out of the one flavor (tamarind) I would have ordered that day.

Desano’s Pizza is a mini-chain of three locations (Nashville, Charleston, LA) serving thin-crust, wood-fired pizzas to diners at long picnic tables in a dining hall in sight of the three ovens. It’s a little above-average for this style of pizza, with the crust a little too thick underneath the toppings and the sauce definitely too garlicky for me, definitely a good spot for a group outing though.

I tried to go to Barista Parlor, the over-the-top coffee emporium on the east side of Nashville, but their espresso machine was down that morning, so I’ll have to save that for another trip. I did make it back to Crema, still the best local roaster I’ve found in Nashville, not quite at the level of direct-trade spots like Intelligentsia or Counter Culture but at the high end of the next tier.

Comments

  1. I ate at Two Ten a few weeks ago and loved. I work in an Izakaya, so I always seek them out when visiting cities. Two Ten would be in my top 3. they had a Saba (mackerel) sashimi that was so good I had to order a second.

  2. I should also mention that my wife and I visited Rolf & Daughters based on your review. Really enjoyed it. Thanks

    • Awesome, glad you enjoyed it. Have you mentioned where you work before? I feel like you might have, but it’s in a city I don’t often visit (SF?).

  3. Josh Engleman

    My wife and I are heading to Nashville this coming weekend for our anniversary. I looked back through your previous posts on Nashville eats, but wanted to ask anyway. If you could only pick one dinner spot based on places you’ve been, what would it be? Catbird Seat is out of the question. No open reservations, unfortunately.

    • Without knowing anything about your specific tastes, I’d say City House or Husk. Husk is better reviewed, and Husk Charleston was amazing, but I had a better meal at City House than I did at Husk Nashville, and I think CH’s food is a little more accessible.

  4. Josh Engleman

    Wanted to circle back to this and just remember to take the menu out of my suitcase. We ended up going to Husk> We sat at the bar and decided to try a few “Firsts” instead of getting entrees. We did the griddle cakes (my wife’s favorite), the charcuterie plate (I loved the beef pate), beef tartare (by far, my favorite) and crispy chicken skins w/ Alabama white sauce (amazing). I enjoyed absolutely everything we had. Not that we were surprised.

    We also ended up going to Pinewood Social, only I didn’t realize you had mentioned it in a previous review until we got home. My wife got some toasts, which she said were good, but didn’t realize they were as small as they were. I stuck to the cocktails. Absolutely excellent selection. Great bourbon, if that’s your thing.

    Next time you’re in Nashville, I highly recommend Monell’s for breakfast. It’s essentially an old house. Everyone gets seated family style, so we were with a group of ~10 other strangers. They bring out everything you could imagine a southern breakfast would entail. Fried chicken, biscuits and gravy, assorted meats, cheese grits, corn pudding, etc. The food was good, obviously not meant to be fancy, but the environment was really fun.

    I had some Hot Chicken at Party Fowl. Never had it before, anywhere, so I can’t really comment on where it ranks, but I wasn’t particularly impressed.