<
>
EXCLUSIVE CONTENT
Get ESPN+

Spirit of instant replay is lost in the minutiae

Instant replay isn't being used the way it was intended to, as reviewers are being asked to evaluate trivial details instead of focusing on getting wrong calls correct. AP Photo/Alex Brandon

The use of instant replay in Major League Baseball has made the game better, on balance, but like any new technology -- and like a lot of MLB policies in general -- it has created a lot of unforeseen consequences as well. This week's brouhaha revolves around slides into second base (or third, although that didn't come up this time around), where a player reaches a base safely by sliding, loses contact with it briefly due to the momentum of his body carrying him forward and over the bag, and is then called out after a review because the infielder wisely kept the tag applied throughout the play.

Such a call was simply impossible prior to replay because there was no way an umpire would see this temporary disconnection with the naked eye -- they have a hard enough time with easier calls -- but slow-motion or frame-by-frame replay have opened up this new, technically accurate call. It is within the letter of the law, but I think it violates the spirit.